FTSE 100 DB pension risk falls by 23.5% since 2017

The aggregate risk across FTSE 100 defined benefit pension schemes has fallen by 23.5 per cent since 2017, according to Cardano and Lincoln Pensions.

The latest Worry Index research from the firms seeks to provide a single measure of the overall safety (or not) of DB schemes. This year’s figure is the lowest level for the past four years. This reflects positive investment returns, additional sponsor contributions and a relatively benign environment for the sponsor covenant, the firms said.

Since 2015, the DB pension risk within FTSE 100 schemes has reduced by 9.4 per cent. Cardano and Lincoln Pensions started publicly publishing its Worry Index score in 2017 as part of efforts for greater transparency around the pensions risk underwritten by the corporate landscape. Cardano chief executive Kerrin Rosenberg described the results as “encouraging”.

However, one in eight FTSE 100 companies with DB obligations are still in the ‘worry zone’ and are still vulnerable, particularly in the event of a major economic shock such as that experienced in 2008. Under a stress scenario, the aggregate FTSE 100 pension deficit would still increase by an estimated £97bn, leaving some companies with a pension deficit bigger than the value of their sponsor.

Risks are particularly concentrated in the consumer services industry, driven by the retail sector, which has one of the highest worry scores of any FTSE industry. One in three retailers with DB liabilities is in the worry zone (DB pension deficit representing at least 30 per cent of market capitalisation), prompting a wider analysis of the position of this market segment across the FTSE 350.

Five of the 11 FTSE 350 retailers with DB obligations are running risks which threaten their ability to withstand stress scenarios, a finding which bears out the broader challenges currently facing the UK’s high street. In the past year, tougher trading conditions have claimed a number of high street stalwarts including Maplin and Toys ‘R’ Us with a number of others such as House of Fraser being rescued from administration through the injection of new capital; in many cases, the pension schemes of failed business are destined for the Pension Protection Fund (PPF).

Commenting, Lincoln Pensions chief executive Darren Redmayne: “As an industry, we must get ever more sophisticated in our assessment of risk. There is still too much focus on deficit figures – but this is just one measure of underlying risk. A large deficit may be tolerable if there is a robust covenant standing behind it: a pension is only as good as the company or entity supporting the risk.”

    Share Story:

Recent Stories


FREE E-NEWS SIGN UP

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive breaking news and other industry announcements by email.

  Please tick here to confirm you are happy to receive third party promotions from carefully selected partners.


Helping the credit challenged get mortgage ready
A rising number of borrowers are finding it harder to access mortgages due to being credit challenged - whether that’s from historic debts, a county court judgment, or having little to no credit history.

In the latest episode of the Mortgage Insider podcast, Phil Spencer is joined by Eloise Hall, Head of National Accounts at Kensington Mortgages, and Alastair Douglas, CEO of TotallyMoney.


Inside the world of high net worth lending
The mortgage market continues to evolve, and so too does the answer to the question: what is a high net worth individual in today’s market? In this episode of the Mortgage Insider podcast, host Phil Spencer is joined by Stephen Moroukian, Head of Product and Proposition for Real Estate Financing at Barclays Private Bank, and Islay Robinson, founder and CEO of Enness Global. Together, they explore what brokers really need to know when supporting high net worth individuals.

The future of the bridging industry and the Autumn Budget
MoneyAge content editor, Dan McGrath, is joined by head of marketing at Black & White Bridging, Matt Horton, to discuss the bridging industry, the impact of the Autumn Budget and what the future holds for the sector.