‘Not cost effective’ to fix pensions tax relief anomaly

The government has reiterated its position on the net pay anomaly, after it said that it is “not cost effective” to reform pensions tax relief which could see workers miss out on up to £60m a year.

Responding to questions from the Treasury Committee last Friday, 26 April, Chancellor Philip Hammond said that he is “not sighted to small detail”, but that it would be a “challenge” to intervene in a cost-effective manner where it cannot be done automatically.

The anomaly stems from the difference between the income tax threshold, which recently rose to £12,500 a year, and the auto-enrolment thresholds, which remained at £10,000.

Savers earning less than the personal allowance will not be credited with tax relief.

Hammond told the committee: “I have to tell you that I am not sighted on the detail. The Economic Secretary [John Glen] is right that the challenge for us in anything around auto-enrolment or small-scale savings is to make an intervention cost effective where it cannot be done automatically, and you have already explained why it cannot be.”

Earlier this month, Royal London estimated that roughly 1.75 million workers could be missing out on the tax relief, which can range from £35 to £720 a year.

However, research from Now Pensions last year found that individuals could be missing out on as much as £64 per year, suggesting the total figure could be much more.

According to the mutual insurer, around three quarters of the workers are women in low-paid or part-time work.

The issue stems from workers whose employers have chosen a Group Personal Pension arrangement, which benefits from a relief at source method, while workers in most trust-based occupational schemes get no tax relief.

Last October, the government rejected calls from the Treasury Committee to fundamentally reform pensions tax relief after it said there was “no clear consensus” to do so.

    Share Story:

Recent Stories


FREE E-NEWS SIGN UP

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive breaking news and other industry announcements by email.

  Please tick here to confirm you are happy to receive third party promotions from carefully selected partners.


Helping the credit challenged get mortgage ready
A rising number of borrowers are finding it harder to access mortgages due to being credit challenged - whether that’s from historic debts, a county court judgment, or having little to no credit history.

In the latest episode of the Mortgage Insider podcast, Phil Spencer is joined by Eloise Hall, Head of National Accounts at Kensington Mortgages, and Alastair Douglas, CEO of TotallyMoney.


Inside the world of high net worth lending
The mortgage market continues to evolve, and so too does the answer to the question: what is a high net worth individual in today’s market? In this episode of the Mortgage Insider podcast, host Phil Spencer is joined by Stephen Moroukian, Head of Product and Proposition for Real Estate Financing at Barclays Private Bank, and Islay Robinson, founder and CEO of Enness Global. Together, they explore what brokers really need to know when supporting high net worth individuals.

The future of the bridging industry and the Autumn Budget
MoneyAge content editor, Dan McGrath, is joined by head of marketing at Black & White Bridging, Matt Horton, to discuss the bridging industry, the impact of the Autumn Budget and what the future holds for the sector.