Poor credit history accounts for almost 30% of tenant referencing declines

Almost a third of unsuccessful tenant referencing applications involve adverse credit history, including county court judgements (CCJs), poor credit scores and insolvency, according to analysis by Propoly.

The lettings technology provider used its internal rental intelligence data to examine tenant referencing outcomes, finding that 62% of applicants pass checks outright, while a further 29% receive conditional approval. Just 6.4% are declined.

Of those rejected, 29.4% have at least one adverse-credit reason recorded, with CCJs alone accounting for 14.8% of declines. The findings show how previous financial difficulties can continue to affect renters seeking a new home, even when their circumstances may have subsequently improved.

Affordability is the most frequently cited primary reason for rejection, accounting for 31.8% of declined applications. A further 19.7% relate to insufficient or unverified proof of income, while employment circumstances, including temporary work, zero-hours contracts and short-term employment, account for 6.2%. Suspected fraud represents just 0.8% of declines.

However, failing an individual referencing requirement does not necessarily result in outright rejection, Propoly found. Of applicants who failed the affordability assessment, only 9.5% were declined, while 54% were accepted subject to a guarantor or other conditions. A further 35% passed overall.

Sim Sekhon, Propoly group CEO, said: "With the cost of living continuing to put pressure on household finances, it is perhaps unsurprising that credit history is playing a significant role in tenant referencing outcomes. Previous financial difficulties, missed payments or a CCJ can follow renters into their next property search, even when their circumstances may have since changed.

"However, it is important to remember that a failed referencing check does not automatically mean the end of the road. Ultimately, tenant referencing should be about understanding the full picture, not simply looking for reasons to say no. By identifying where additional reassurance is needed, rather than treating every failed criteria as an outright rejection, the industry can help more people find a route into a home while giving landlords greater confidence in their decisions."



Share Story:

Recent Stories


FREE E-NEWS SIGN UP

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive breaking news and other industry announcements by email.

  Please tick here to confirm you are happy to receive third party promotions from carefully selected partners.


AI, finfluencers and the future of broking
The mortgage industry is evolving faster than ever. In this MoneyAge video, we examine the opportunities and challenges redefining the broker landscape, from AI-powered lending and changing customer expectations to housing affordability, property supply and the rise of financial influencers. Our guest from Chorley Building Society shares practical insights on what brokers need to do to stay relevant and thrive in a rapidly changing market.

Pure Retirement and the role of lifetime mortgages
Senior content editor Dan McGrath is joined by strategic account manager at Pure Retirement, Tash Phillips, to discuss the lifetime mortgage market, the role of equity release in the industry and how the firm’s range of products, including its interest servicing lifetime mortgage, can serve the sector moving forward in the ever-changing lending space.

Perenna and the long-term fixed mortgage market
Content editor, Dan McGrath, spoke to head of product, proposition and distribution at Perenna, John Davison, to explore the long-term fixed mortgage market, the role that Perenna plays in this sector and the impact of the recent Autumn Budget

NEW BUILD IN FOCUS - NEW EPISODE OF THE MORTGAGE INSIDER PODCAST, OUT NOW
Figures from the National House-Building Council saw Q1 2025 register a 36% increase in new homes built across the UK compared with the same period last year, representing a striking development for the first-time buyer market. But with the higher cost of building, ongoing planning challenges and new and changing regulations, how sustainable is this growth? And what does it mean for brokers?